A cross-complaint in California is a formal pleading that lets a party who has been sued bring its own claims in the same state court case. The person or business that files it is the cross-complainant. The party named in it is the cross-defendant. Depending on the claim, a cross-defendant can be the original plaintiff, another party already in the case, or someone brought into the case for the first time.
How A Cross Complaint Differs From An Answer?
An answer responds to the allegations and raises defenses. A cross-complaint asks the court to grant relief on a claim of your own, such as damages for breach of contract. A business can file both pleadings in the same case.
In a payment dispute, the retailer could deny that payment is due in its answer. If it also wants to recover what it paid to replace defective goods, it can ask for those damages in a cross-complaint. Which claims and defenses the retailer can assert will depend on the contract and the evidence.
When California Requires A Cross Complaint?
A claim is generally compulsory when you already have it against the party suing you when you serve your answer and it arises from the same transaction, event, or series of events as the claim against you. If you leave out a compulsory claim, California law generally bars you from asserting it against that party in a later lawsuit. Statutory exceptions can apply.
For example, a supplier sues a retailer for unpaid invoices. If the retailer already has a claim for losses caused by defective goods in those same shipments, that claim may be compulsory. The purchase orders, delivery records and communications can help establish how the claims relate.
When A Cross Complaint Is Optional?
A permissive cross-complaint asserts a claim that you may bring in the same case but are generally free to pursue separately, subject to applicable deadlines and procedural rules. For example, a retailer sued over an unpaid shipment might have a separate claim against the supplier under an unrelated equipment lease.
Claims against a party who did not sue you follow a different rule. They must arise from the same transaction or events or concern a right or interest in the property or dispute at issue. For example, a general contractor sued over a water leak might seek indemnity from the subcontractor that installed the affected plumbing if the subcontract or applicable law supports that claim.
Deadlines For Filing A Cross Complaint
File a cross-complaint against a party who sued you before or at the same time as your answer. Other cross-complaints can generally be filed before the court sets a trial date. Once the applicable filing window has passed, you need the court’s permission to file.
If you omitted a compulsory claim, you can ask the court for permission to add it while the case is pending. After notice to the opposing party, the court must grant leave if you acted in good faith, subject to any terms the court considers just. (Code Civ. Proc. § 426.50)
Before deciding whether to file, give counsel the complaint, any scheduling orders and a short timeline. Identify who signed the contract, who performed the work and what each party allegedly did. If you seek damages, gather documents showing how you calculated the loss, such as repair estimates, replacement invoices or records of payments already made. Flag any deadlines shown on the papers you received.
What To Do If You Are Served?
California generally gives a cross-defendant 30 days after service to file a response. The method of service and any applicable extension or court order can affect the deadline. Keep the papers, record when and how they were served, and have counsel confirm your response date. A missed deadline can put you at risk of default.
Gather the agreements, invoices, emails and project records tied to the allegations. If the dispute may involve insurance or a contractual right to indemnity, review any notice requirements with counsel.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can An Original Plaintiff Become A Cross-Defendant?
Yes. If the original defendant files a cross-complaint against the plaintiff, the plaintiff keeps that role on the original claims and becomes a cross-defendant on the new claims.
Does A New Cross-Defendant Need To Receive Summons?
Yes. A party who has yet to appear in the action must be served with a cross-complaint summons and the cross-complaint. A party who has already appeared is served with the cross-complaint under the rules for serving papers in the pending case.
Discuss Your Case With Tropea McMillan LLP
If your business has been sued or served with a cross-complaint, Tropea McMillan LLP can help you evaluate your claims, defenses and filing deadlines. Contact Tropea McMillan LLP or call 866-977-8921 to discuss your case.
